A founder’s guide to understanding nonprofit leadership

Let’s talk about something that often causes confusion in the nonprofit world: ownership. If you’ve ever caught yourself saying “my nonprofit” (don’t worry, we’ve all been there!), this post is for you.

If you scroll through social media groups, you’ll find others giving similar advice to people seeking answers. I want to expand on the quick advice I usually see.

The Big Misconception

Here’s the truth bomb: Nobody owns a nonprofit organization. Not even you, the founder who poured your heart, soul, and countless sleepless nights into creating it.

“But wait,” you might be thinking, “I started this organization! I filed all the paperwork! I built it from nothing!”

You’re absolutely right – you did build it. And you did a great job! But here’s where things get interesting…

Understanding Public Benefit

Once you receive your 501(c)3 tax-exempt status from the IRS, you now run a public charity. There are other types of tax exempt organizations, but I’ll keep this simple for right now.

Let’s break this down into simple terms:

Public Charity (n.): An organization that belongs to the public and operates for public benefit, overseen by a board of directors.

Think of your nonprofit like a public park:

• The park serves the community
• The city maintains and manages it
• But no one person “owns” it
• Everyone has a stake in its success

The Legal Perspective

Here’s what the IRS says about nonprofits:

• They are organized and operated exclusively for exempt purposes
• No part of their net earnings may benefit any private shareholder or individual (this does not apply salaries of staff!)
• They are considered public entities serving public interests

In other words: Your nonprofit belongs to the community it serves!

What You Actually Have

Instead of ownership, you have:

• Leadership: The ability to guide and direct according to the mission and vision
• Responsibility: The duty to serve the mission
• Stewardship: The role of managing resources – all the administrative and programmatic stuff
• Vision: The power to shape the organization’s future

Common Founder Pitfalls to Avoid

The Personal Bank Account Trap

• ❌ Using nonprofit funds for personal expenses – big no-no
• ✅ Maintaining strict financial boundaries – policies and documentation are your friend

The Solo Decision Maker

• ❌ Making all decisions without board input
• ✅ Embracing collaborative governance

The Forever Chair

• ❌ Assuming you’ll always lead the board
• ✅ Planning for succession and shared leadership – this is a step many forget

Best Practices for Founders

Establish Clear Boundaries

• Separate personal and organizational assets
• Create transparent financial procedures
• Document decision-making processes

Build a Strong Board

• Recruit diverse, qualified board members
• Share power and responsibility
• Welcome different perspectives

Think Succession from Day One

• Document your processes
• Train future leaders
• Create sustainability plans

Legal Requirements to Remember

Your nonprofit must have:

• A board of directors (minimum number varies by state, usually 3 besides yourself)
• Regular board meetings with minutes
• Conflict of interest policies
• Financial oversight procedures
• Public disclosure of certain documents (Form 990, every year whether you make money or not)

The Founder’s True Role

As a new founder, you will discover that you will take on many roles in the beginning. Think of yourself as a:

• Steward rather than an owner, you are taking care of things
• Leader rather than a boss – there are great resources out there to help you
• Facilitator rather than a controller
• Vision-keeper rather than a dictator

Moving Forward

Understanding that you don’t “own” your nonprofit isn’t about diminishing your role – it’s about embracing a bigger purpose. Your organization can actually grow stronger when you:

• Share responsibility
• Build sustainable systems
• Engage others in leadership
• Focus on mission over control

Remember: The most successful nonprofit founders aren’t those who hold on tightest, but those who build organizations that can thrive even without them.

Your Next Steps

1. Review your language – shift from “my nonprofit” to “our organization”
2. Assess your board’s involvement in decision-making, if they are helping it may be time for some basic board training
3. Start documenting your processes – in print or digitally
4. Plan for your organization’s future beyond your leadership

Do you need help implementing these changes? Leave a comment below or contact me or your state’s nonprofit association for resources and guidance.

---

Pro Tip: Share this article with your board members and use it to start a conversation about organizational governance and succession planning.

What challenges have you faced in separating your founder role from ownership? Share your experiences in the comments!